The Validation Canvas for young founders
You have an idea. Maybe it is a good one. This course will not tell you that, because nobody can. It will show you how to find out for yourself, one honest step at a time, before you spend your money or your Saturdays on a guess. There is a one-page idea card to start with, seven short modules with a box to fill in for your own idea, a table of the grown-up words, and four young founders whose decisions are followed all the way to an answer. Everything you write is saved on this device.
BeginMost people with an idea ask one question: is it good? That question cannot be answered, by you or by anyone else, and it gets answered anyway, by whoever is most confident, by how you feel today, or by a friend who would never say no to you. This course asks a different question: what are you about to spend on this idea, and has the idea earned it yet? That question has an answer, because you can check it.
Here is how the course is arranged. First, an idea card: one page where you write down what you are counting on. Then seven modules. Each one teaches one part of the method and ends with a box you fill in for your own idea. The ten questions before you start. The eight things you have to be honest about, and a ninth the canvas works out by itself. The seven questions every claim has to answer, and the five-step scale that says how much your evidence is worth. The bar your idea has to clear, and the gate that checks it. Then the answer, with its conditions. At the end there is a table of the grown-up words, because the boxes you fill in here are the same boxes real founders use. Only the labels are different.
Watch the film for the idea card, then read on. Film, 5 min 01, with captions.
Before the seven modules, fill in one card. It takes five short answers, and it is the shortest honest description of a business idea there is. You will come back to it at the end, and you will probably change it. That is what it is for.
The five questions are: What am I counting on? Who pays, and with what? What would count as proof? What does it cost me? What is the first test? Each one has a box below. Write a guess if a guess is all you have. A guess written down can be checked. A guess kept in your head cannot.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 5 min 48, with captions.
Most people think a business plan is for working out whether an idea is good. Nobody can work that out. So this canvas asks a different question first: what exactly am I about to spend on this, and has the idea earned it yet? “Good” is a feeling. “Earned” is something you can check against evidence. The whole course is built on that swap.
Before you fill in anything else, you answer ten short questions. grown-up name: the decision frame They are: the idea in one sentence; who the customer is, as a real person; what is going on for them; what you want out of it; what you are deciding; what it will cost you; when you have to decide by; what going ahead actually means; what success looks like, as a number; and what would make you stop. The last two are written now, before you know anything, because a target you set after seeing the results is not a target. In the tool, the answer stays locked until all ten are filled in. That lock is the first rule of the method.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 5 min 42, with captions.
With the ten questions done, the canvas asks eight more, one at a time. Each one pins down something specific. grown-up name: the eight areas They are: who actually has the problem, and who pays; what they really want and what they are worried about; how big the problem is next to what they do now; what you are promising, and where the promise stops; how they will find out about you; what they have to do, risk or pay to say yes; whether the sums work; and whether you can make and deliver it every time, not just once.
How you answer matters more than how much you write. Each of the eight wants a claim, not an essay: one or two sentences that could later be shown to be wrong. “Teenagers like hoodies” cannot be wrong, so it is worth nothing. “Sixth-formers who search Depop by brand will pay £18 for a clean hoodie in their size” can be wrong, so it is a claim. “I don’t know yet” is a good answer too. Written down, it becomes a question with your name on it. Left blank, it becomes a gap that quietly votes yes.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 5 min 55, with captions.
This is the part no other canvas does. You do not fill in the ninth thing. The canvas works it out by holding your eight answers up against each other and asking one question: can all of these be true at the same time? grown-up name: coherence You wrote each answer on its own, maybe on its own day. When two of them clash, it is not because you were careless. It is what perfectly reasonable answers do when they have never been read together.
A clash always has the same shape: two answers, each fine on its own, impossible together. A promise to post within two days, and a parcelshop you can only reach on Saturdays. A refund promise that makes saying yes easy, and a sum that only works if no parcel ever comes back. Nobody wrote a contradiction on purpose. The clash check exists because the most expensive mistakes in a business are not wrong answers. They are two answers that cannot both be true, and you cannot see that from inside either one.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 5 min 58, with captions.
Underneath every one of the eight things, the canvas runs the same seven questions, and they never change. grown-up name: the evidence layer What are you claiming? Why do you believe it? What have you actually seen? What does not fit? What breaks if you are wrong? What would you test next? And what result would count as a pass? The first three show how little most claims rest on. The last two turn that into something to do.
Two of the seven do most of the work. What does not fit makes you write down the evidence against you, and an empty line there almost never means there is none. It means nobody looked. What breaks if you are wrong asks how much the whole idea leans on this one claim: does it fall over, does it wobble, or does it barely notice? grown-up name: criticality: load-bearing, material, supporting That label is what the gate reads later, so it is worth an argument now. Most claims feel as if the whole idea leans on them. Most do not. The one that does deserves your next test.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 6 min 07, with captions.
Once a claim has some evidence behind it, the canvas asks how strong that evidence is, and it grades on a five-step scale. grown-up name: the evidence scale Step one: I think so. Step two: they said so. Step three: I saw it myself. Step four: they did something. Step five: they paid. The steps translate what people say into what it is actually worth, and the exchange rate is strict. “I would definitely buy one”, said warmly by a real person, is still step two.
The scale keeps itself honest with ceilings. Evidence that is people saying things stops at step two, however many people and however excited they are. Evidence of people doing things (replying, saving a listing, turning up, giving you their time) stops at step four. Only paying reaches step five. This is not unkind about your friends. It respects the difference between a kind sentence and money changing hands, and every founder who counted kind sentences as customers has paid the difference themselves.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 5 min 50, with captions.
Now the two halves meet. The ten questions told the canvas what you are about to spend. The steps graded what you actually know. This module is the sum between them. Every commitment sits on a ladder: Look, Try, Small run, Go, Grow. grown-up name: the commitment ladder: explore, experiment, pilot, build, scale Each rung sets a bar, from step one up to step five, because the same idea can deserve a yes to a small try and a no to a full launch. “Has this idea earned it?” means nothing until you say what “it” is.
Then the gate reads your claims against the bar, one at a time, never as an average. grown-up name: the gate The rules are short. No claim the idea leans on can sit below the bar. No claim the idea leans on can have evidence against it. The ten questions must be complete, with the targets written in advance. That is why an idea can look strong overall and still fail the gate: seven good answers and one wrong claim that everything leans on is a good-looking idea that does not work. The gate exists so that one broken leg cannot hide behind three good ones. One note about the ladder below: Looking needs no proof at all, and Trying needs a named test rather than a step, because you try something exactly when you do not know yet. From a Small run upward, the steps shown are the usual bar.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 6 min 04, with captions.
The answer is not a score and not a pat on the back. grown-up name: the verdict It is a sentence with parts. A yes comes with conditions, limits and a date to check again, because a yes with no conditions is a mood with a signature. A not-yet names its route, and there are five. Test more, when one named test would settle the open question. Go smaller, when the evidence is real for one group and missing for everyone else. Ask a different question, when the ten questions were pointed at the wrong decision. Wait, with a written trigger for when to come back. And Stop, when the idea has had its fair hearing. Every answer also names the rule that decided it, so you are never arguing with a feeling.
Then the tool does one small thing that matters more than any feature: it writes down its answer and yours, separately. You can overrule it. Sometimes you should, because the canvas reads your claims and you read the world. But the difference is written down, with your reasons, and it goes into a one-page record with the ten questions, the graded claims and what the gate said. grown-up name: the Validation Decision Report Three months later, that page is the difference between learning from the decision and having the same argument again.
Watch the film for this module, then read on. Film, 6 min 24, with captions.
Every box you filled in on this course is a box on the real Validation Canvas. The same ten questions. The same eight things. The same seven questions under each claim, the same five steps, the same bar, the same gate, the same routes. Real founders, with real money on the table, use exactly this. The only thing that was different here was the labels.
The table below bridges the two sets of words. Read it once, and the adult tool will not feel like a different instrument. Your mentor can point at this page whenever a grown-up word turns up. When you are ready, press Export my work at the foot of this page, open the real tool, go to Canvases and choose Import JSON. Your ten answers arrive in its frame and your eight answers as claims in its eight areas, marked untested until you add evidence there; the claims you graded here travel in its notes, for you to place in the right area. The real tool keeps its work in the browser you use, so export a backup from it as well. The idea card is this edition’s own; its five answers are a short form of the ten questions and the central claim.
| What we called it here | What the real tool and grown-ups call it |
|---|---|
| Writing it down doesn’t make it true | Filled in is not the same as proven |
| The ten questions before you start | The decision frame |
| The eight things you have to be honest about | The eight areas |
| Who really has the problem, and who pays | Customer reality |
| What they want, and what they are worried about | Psychology and motivation |
| How big the problem is, and what they do now | Problem and alternatives |
| The promise, and where it stops | Offer |
| How they will hear about you | Communication and access |
| What they have to do, risk or pay to say yes | Conversion and commitment |
| The sums | Economics |
| Making it happen | Operations |
| The clash check | Strategic coherence, the ninth area |
| The seven questions every claim has to answer | The evidence layer |
| Why I believe it / What I have seen / What does not fit | Basis / Evidence / Counter-evidence |
| The whole idea falls over / wobbles / barely notices | Load-bearing / Material / Supporting (criticality) |
| The five steps: I think so, They said so, I saw it, They did something, They paid | The evidence scale: untested belief, anecdotal indication, observed reality, behavioural evidence, commercial evidence |
| Said / Did / Paid ceilings | The said, done and paid caps |
| The ladder: Look, Try, Small run, Go, Grow | The commitment ladder: Explore, Experiment, Pilot, Build, Scale |
| A claim the idea leans on | A load-bearing assumption |
| The bar and the gate | The bar and the gate (unchanged) |
| The answer | The verdict |
| Go / Test more / Go smaller / Ask a different question / Wait / Stop | Proceed / Test further / Narrow / Reframe / Pause / Stop |
| The one-page record | The Validation Decision Report |
Here is the whole method, start to finish. The idea card says what you are counting on. The ten questions turn an idea into a decision with a deadline and a target. The eight things turn the decision into claims. The clash check reads the claims against each other. The seven questions put a price on each claim, and the five steps grade what it rests on, with a ceiling set by what kind of evidence it is. The bar rises to meet the commitment, the gate reads the claims one at a time, and the answer comes back with conditions or a route, the rule named, your call written down next to the tool’s. Nothing in the loop is clever. Its whole power is that no step can be skipped quietly.
Now use it. Open the interactive tool with your mentor, write down the thing you are actually about to spend money or Saturdays on, and run it through, badly, tonight. Your first canvas will be thin. That thinness is useful: it is a map of what you do not know yet, in order. You have finished this course when a real decision of yours has been through the loop, the one-page record exists, and something changed because of what it said. If the decision involves an account, a payment or an age rule, that is the moment to ask a parent or a teacher.