The Horizontal Validation Canvas, module 06

Earned what?

The same idea can deserve a yes to an experiment and a no to a launch. The commitment you are weighing sets the evidence bar.

Five rungs

Each rung sets an evidence bar

The commitment ladder as five rising steps Explore has no evidence bar, Experiment needs a named test, Pilot typically needs level three, observed reality, Build level four, behavioural evidence, and Scale level five, commercial evidence. The Young Founders edition calls them Look, Try, Small run, Go and Grow. ExploreNo bar. Go and look. ExperimentBar: a named test. PilotBar: level 3.Observed reality. Build or launchBar: level 4.Behavioural evidence. ScaleBar: level 5.Commercial evidence. LOOK TRY SMALL RUN GO GROW

These are the typical bars. From Pilot upward the tool sets the bar area by area. The Young Founders edition calls the same rungs Look, Try, Small run, Go and Grow.

Name the commitment with a number

Money, people, months

Should we do this?Not a decision. Nothing to weigh, no rung, no bar.
Should we commit 60k and two engineers for six months?A decision. The rung is Build, so the bar is level 4.

Choose the rung honestly

Most asks are Build wearing Pilot's clothes

The commonest distortion is stating the commitment one rung low to shop for an easier bar. Six months of two engineers is a number wearing a schedule.

If the money and the people are Build-sized, the bar is Build's, whatever the slide calls it.

At Halden Systems, an illustrative firm

The size of the yes changed

The ask was Build: 60k, two engineers, six months. Bar: level four. Three load-bearing assumptions read against it.

5, 3, 3Willingness to pay, delivery cost, the boundary holding under pressure

Verdict, as asked: blocked. Two load-bearing assumptions below a Build bar.

BlockedThe rule, named

The rung below: a segment-bounded pilot with templating as an explicit goal. All three meet a Pilot bar of three.

PassesThe idea did not fail

The rule

The commitment you are weighing sets the evidence bar.

The ladder is not only a test you pass or fail. It is a menu. When a Build is blocked, ask what the rung below would let you learn before the board asks again.