The Horizontal Validation Canvas

Five levels.
Three caps.

Every important claim is graded by what actually supports it, not by how convinced you are.

The evidence scale

Five levels, in order of strength

The five evidence levels as rising steps Untested belief, anecdotal indication, observed reality, behavioural evidence and commercial evidence, each step higher than the last. 1Untested beliefSomeone thinks so. 2Anecdotal indicationA few people said so. 3Observed realityIt was seen or measured. 4Behavioural evidencePeople did something. 5Commercial evidencePeople paid.

The caps

Saying caps at two. Doing caps at four. Only paying reaches five.

The said, done and paid caps drawn over the five steps A dashed line at level two labelled said, a dashed line at level four labelled done, and the top step labelled paid. SAID · CAPS AT 2 DONE · CAPS AT 4 PAID · REACHES 5

However many people, and however enthusiastic. It is respect for the difference between a kind sentence and a bank transfer.

The same customer, two sentences

Warm words are not demand

I would definitely buy this.Said warmly, in a real meeting. Might still be level 2.
Here is the deposit.Materially stronger. Level 4, and level 5 once the money clears.

At Halden Systems, an illustrative firm

The scale did its work

Eleven regulated practices were offered the subscription at full price. Five signed and paid their first month.

Level 5One claim, one segment. Nothing yet about the other 180 clients.

Six warm expressions of interest from the original quarterly reviews.

Level 2Three of the six were offered the same deal. None signed.

The rule

Grade by what produced it, not by how convinced you are.

A claim qualifies at a level. It does not earn points, and levels are never averaged across claims.