A worked example, with illustrative figures

See what else changes before you commit.

One service business, one sensible-looking price change, and the three places it lands that the first spreadsheet never showed.

The decision as first framed

A premium package at 1,200 instead of 1,000

Today: 20 jobs a month at 1,000 each, costing 700 to deliver. Contribution before overheads: 6,000 a month.

6,000Today, per month

The proposal: a premium package at 1,200. The extra work it includes raises delivery cost to 850 a job.

+200 price+150 delivery cost

The first spreadsheet stops here: 350 contribution a job instead of 300. It looks like a yes.

350 a jobWas 300

First consequence: economics

The price alone does not settle it

If volume holds at 2020 jobs at 350 contribution: 7,000 a month, up from 6,000. The case the proposal assumed.
If volume falls to 1616 jobs at 350: 5,600 a month, down from 6,000. Four buyers who will not pay 1,200 wipe out the gain. Nobody has asked them yet.

Whether buyers accept 1,200 is an untested belief, and the whole case rests on it.

Second consequence: operations

Then move horizontally

The extra work takes delivery from 10 hours a job to 13. Capacity available: 220 hours a month, against 200 used today.

220 hAvailable

At 20 premium jobs: 260 hours. The attractive case is the one the business cannot deliver without a change.

260 h40 over

At 16 jobs: 208 hours. It fits, and it earns less than today.

208 hFits, earns 5,600

What is known and what is assumed

Three figures are facts. Three are hopes.

KnownToday's price, delivery cost and hours per job. The 220 hours available. These came from the books and the diary.
AssumedThat buyers accept 1,200. That the extra work really takes 13 hours. That volume holds. None has been tested, so each is level one on the evidence scale.

A build-sized commitment on level-one claims is blocked. The rung below is an experiment, which needs a named test, not a level.

The useful output

Not a verdict. A bounded test with an owner and a date.

  1. 1Offer the premium package to the next eight enquiries only, for one month, with existing clients untouched.
  2. 2Write the threshold first: how many of the eight must accept, and what the delivered hours must come in under, for the case to stand. The business sets those numbers, not this deck.
  3. 3Name the owner, cap the exposure (no hires, no new tooling), and fix the review date before the first conversation.