Eight strong areas and one wrong load-bearing belief is a strong-looking business that does not work.
The rules are short
What the gate reads
1No load-bearing assumption below the bar.
2No load-bearing assumption contradicted by the evidence.
3The frame complete, with its thresholds written in advance.
It reads them one at a time. That is the whole mechanism.
Why an average is the wrong instrument
Averages are how fatal holes hide inside good numbers
The average of the eight is 4.3, which clears the bar. The gate's reading: blocked, because one load-bearing assumption is below the bar.
Two states a scorecard blurs
Below the bar is a gap. Contradicted is an answer.
A gapAn assumption below the bar. A named test could close it, and the next test goes there.
An answerAn assumption contradicted by evidence. The evidence has already spoken. Treating it as a gap to fill keeps the idea alive on paper.
The verdict
Not a score. Not a blessing. A sentence with parts.
A proceed names its conditions, its limits and its review date. A do-not-proceed names its route.
Proceed, with conditions
Test further
Narrow
Reframe
Pause, with a trigger
Stop
Every verdict names the rule that decided it. You are never left arguing with a feeling.
At Halden Systems, an illustrative firm
Nobody argued about whether the idea was good. The argument had moved to the evidence, where judgement still decides.
The whole-base Build was blocked: two load-bearing assumptions below a Build bar. The route, narrow, and the rule went into the board pack. The board read one page, asked two questions, and approved a narrowed pilot in eleven minutes.